Colorado Politics

Missy Woods accepts plea deal, avoids trial on 102 felony counts

The former top Colorado Bureau of Investigation forensic scientist accused of altering and deleting DNA evidence in scores of criminal cases across the state for years pleaded guilty to four criminal counts Tuesday in Jefferson County.

Yvonne “Missy” Woods, 65, changed her plea rather than face trial on 102 felony charges that included one count of cybercrime, one count of perjury, 48 counts of attempt to influence a public servant and 52 counts of forgery.

She now faces up to 16 years in prison after pleading guilty to four counts of the original indictment. Jefferson County District Judge Andrew Poland accepted the pleas.

Woods had initially pleaded not guilty to all charges in February, more than a year after her arrest. Her trial, expected to last more than a month, had been scheduled to begin in September.

Sentencing is scheduled for Sept. 8.

Missy Woods leaves the Jefferson County Courthouse with her friends and family after pleading guilty to 4 counts
Missy Woods leaves the Jefferson County Courthouse with her friends and family after pleading guilty to counts of cybercrime, perjury, attempt to influence a public servant and forgery on Tuesday. (Stephen Swofford, Denver Gazette)

She pleaded guilty to one of each of the charges she faced, the most serious being the cybercrime. She faces from eight to 16 years on that count. Had she been found guilty at trial, she could have faced up to 24 years on that count and a fine of up to $1 million.

On Tuesday, she also pleaded guilty to one count of perjury, forgery and attempt to influence a public servant. While those counts also carry prison time, she will serve those sentences concurrently, according to the plea agreement.

Jefferson County Deputy District Attorney Darren Kafka said at the brief hearing Tuesday morning that his office had insisted that Woods serve time in prison for her crimes, adding they had significant impact on the community.

Woods, dressed in a black pantsuit with her hair pulled back in a bun, spoke calmly and clearly when asked if she understood the plea arrangement and that she was waiving her right to trial. As each of the four counts was read, she replied “guilty.”

The CBI issued a statement saying Woods acted alone. Her crimes “constituted intentional criminal fraud carried out by a single individual. The conduct violated the law and professional standards of the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. It was not reflective of CBI’s institutional practices or mission,” according to a news release.

“This moment is not about moving on, for CBI it’s about moving forward,” said Director Armando Saldate in the release. “Today’s guilty plea is an important moment of accountability.”

It added that “CBI has undertaken reforms that go beyond routine compliance and reflect a commitment to national best practices in forensic science.”

A contingent of Woods’ friends and family filled one side of the courtroom and offered support.

On the opposite side of the room, Tamara Dean Harney and her husband, KC Harney, watched the proceedings unfold. Tamara Harney’s father, Roger Dean, was slain in 1985 in Lone Tree and Woods’ analysis had been key to the case.

Dean’s killer, Michael Jefferson, was not arrested until 2021 and was awaiting trial when the CBI scandal broke and Woods’ work was suddenly thrown into question. Prosecutors offered him a plea deal with a reduced sentence rather than risk trial because Woods’ analysis of DNA in the case was potentially no longer seen as credible.

Woods’ defense attorneys, Tom Ward and Lindsay Brown, said on Tuesday neither they nor their client would comment at this time.

Woods, once considered the go-to expert at Colorado’s state crime lab for her ability to analyze DNA, especially in tricky cold cases, surrendered to Jefferson County authorities on Jan. 22, 2025 and was released on bond.

Missy Woods walks into the Jefferson County Courthouse on Feb. 20, 2025. (Stephen Swofford, Denver Gazette file)

And while the change of plea on Tuesday closes one chapter of a scandal that has roiled the state’s judicial system, many questions remain unanswered.

It is still unclear how her alleged misconduct not only impacted those now in prison due to her findings but also potential defendants who might have escaped prosecution over the years due to her conclusions.

In her indictment, it was alleged that she changed quantities of DNA found in sexual assault cases to make it appear there was less than actually detected so she could skip analysis.

In Denver, its police lab has reviewed more than 1,000 cases once handled by CBI to check for inconsistencies or problems in the analysis. The result of that review has not been publicly released.

In a 2023 interview with internal investigators, Woods acknowledged, in part, skipping steps as she said she felt overwhelmed by her workload and under pressure from supervisors to clear cases quickly.

The ripple effect of Woods’ alleged misconduct has had far-reaching effects. In at least three murder cases since her arrest, suspects awaiting trial were offered lesser charges and lighter sentences by prosecutors rather than risk taking the cases to trial because of the taint hanging over CBI.

Tamara Harney told The Denver Gazette prior to Tuesday’s hearing that living with the uncertainty surrounding her father’s case and whether his killer would face full consequences because of Woods “left a hole in my chest.”

“After nearly 40 years, the outcome I counted on was weakened by someone who was supposed to protect it,” Harney told The Denver Gazette. “When Missy Woods’ misconduct came out, everything changed.”

On Tuesday, at the conclusion of the proceedings, Harney had mixed feelings.

“I won’t know how satisfied I am until we know what the sentence is,” she said.

In another case with possibly deep implications from the DNA scandal is that of Michael Clark. He was tried and convicted of a 1994 Boulder murder, in large part on the strength of Woods’ DNA analysis in his case.

Clark’s conviction was set aside last year after a retest of the DNA evidence found inconsistent results from what Woods had reported.

Clark, who was convicted in 2012 and spent nearly 13 years in prison of a life-without-parole sentence, is now awaiting a second trial.

CBI has maintained that no one was wrongly convicted because of Woods’ actions. But the full breadth of the impact remains unclear, and some critics, including defense attorneys and some sexual assault victims, say intentionally hidden.

In September 2023, after an intern in the CBI lab became alarmed by some of Woods’ past work, an internal investigation was launched. Woods was allowed to retire with full pension after 29 years at the lab rather than be fired just before the scandal became public in November of that year.

CBI has said it discovered “anomalies,” or some kind of problem, in 1,045 of her cases dating back decades. That means that there were issues found in roughly 1 in 10 of the more than 10,780 cases Woods worked.

Details of the nature of what was uncovered have still not been fully disclosed by CBI as its leadership said it was waiting for her criminal case to be resolved.

An internal CBI investigation after the scandal broke revealed that in both 2014 and 2018, others in the lab alerted supervisors of suspected problems with Woods’ work in criminal cases, but those allegations were never told to prosecutors, defense attorneys or the public.

Other than being briefly removed from duty and ordered to undergo some therapy, Woods faced no consequences from those earlier complaints.

Denver Gazette freelance writer Carol McKinley contributed to this story.

Missy Woods goes into the Jefferson County Courthouse as she prepares to plead guilty to four counts of cybercrime, perjury, attempt to influence a public servant, and forgery on Tuesday, June 23. Woods is expected to serve eight to 16 years for the cybercrime charges, with the other sentences served concurrently.

(Stephen Swofford, Denver Gazette)


PREV

PREVIOUS

Aurora creates police oversight office in final vote

The Aurora City Council voted unanimously Monday to create a police oversight office as the city’s consent decree comes to an end. Without discussion, council members approved a final ordinance creating the Office of Public Safety Accountability, prompting city officials to begin the hiring process. The office will serve as an “independent function reporting administratively […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

Property owners may access evidence before eminent domain decisions, Colorado justices conclude

The Colorado Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday that a Douglas County judge incorrectly believed he lacked the authority to allow a property owner to pursue evidence challenging a government entity’s legal right to take its property through eminent domain. In a June 23 opinion, Justice Susan Blanco wrote that the law does not explicitly provide […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests