judge scott matheson
-
10th Circuit dismisses paralyzed man’s claims against Colorado Springs, officer
—
by
The Denver-based federal appeals court upheld the dismissal last week of a man’s excessive force claims against the city of Colorado Springs and the officer who tased him, causing him to fall down a sloped surface and break his neck. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit declined to…
-
Despite prevailing at SCOTUS, 10th Circuit again rejects man’s age discrimination lawsuit
—
by
Six months after the nation’s highest court ruled that a man could theoretically reopen his age discrimination case to contest an arbitrator’s unfair decision, the Denver-based federal appeals court determined he could not actually do so under the procedural rules. As a result, plaintiff Gary Waetzig cannot challenge his arbitrator’s violation of her arbitration agreement…
-
10th Circuit, 2-1, rules ignoring emergency signal from jail detainees is clear constitutional violation
—
by
The Denver-based federal appeals court concluded on Monday that a jail employee can violate a detainee’s clear constitutional rights by ignoring an emergency distress signal, even if there is no further information about what kind of emergency exists. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit agreed Ralph Marcus Hardy…
-
10th Circuit says judge erred in denying immunity to Denver officers who arrested man for recording
—
by
The Colorado-based federal appeals court sided with two Denver police officers on Tuesday, finding they were entitled to immunity outright or to a second look at their arguments in a lawsuit over a man’s arrest for video recording at a police station. There was no dispute that a sign was posted on the window of…
-
10th Circuit allows Gross Reservoir construction to continue while trial judge sorts out project
—
by
The Colorado-based federal appeals court on Friday permitted construction to continue temporarily on Denver Water’s massive infrastructure project in Boulder County while a trial judge forges ahead with a hearing on the matter. Earlier this month, U.S. District Court Senior Judge Christine M. Arguello found that, as a result of federal law violations, the expansion of…
-
10th Circuit says parents failed to show school policies on gender identity violated their rights
—
by
Two sets of parents failed to show how a Larimer County school district’s policies, which addressed how staff should treat students’ gender identities, were responsible for their “strained” family relationship, the Denver-based federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday. At the same time, one judge suggested a policy enabling staff to keep parents “in the dark” about…
-
‘Common sense’: 10th Circuit rules Loveland officer will face civil trial for shooting puppy in head
—
by
The Denver-based federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday that a jury will decide whether a Loveland police officer violated a couple’s constitutional rights by shooting their puppy in the head and torso. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit had never decided the specific question of whether the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits unreasonable…
-
10th Circuit dismisses man’s lawsuit against Arvada detective, accuser for rape accusation
—
by
The Denver-based federal appeals court agreed last week that a man had not credibly alleged he was prosecuted for rape without probable cause because, in part, he apologized for raping the alleged victim on a recorded phone call. Gary Weidner III sued Detective Kristin Ames and his former romantic partner, identified as “Jane Doe,” after…
-
Federal judge once again dismisses lawsuit of prison employee offended by DEI training
—
by
A federal judge dismissed a second lawsuit on Monday brought by a former Colorado Department of Corrections employee who was offended by an equity training module and alleged it created a hostile work environment. In 2023, U.S. District Court Judge Nina Y. Wang dismissed Joshua F. Young’s first lawsuit on the grounds that he failed…
-
How a Harris or Trump presidency might shape Colorado’s federal courts
—
by
In the past four years, President Joe Biden has made seven appointments to the federal trial and appeals courts headquartered in Colorado, with his appointees now constituting a majority of active judges on the state’s U.S. District Court. The next president will similarly have a chance to make his or her mark on the district…
