Colorado Politics

22 states side with Colorado in asking SCOTUS to take up ‘faithless elector’ case

Twenty-two other states have filed a court brief in support of Colorado’s “faithless elector” case, asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review and reverse the decision of the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals.

The Constitution’s delegation of powers to the states is “sufficiently open-ended to allow conditioning service as an elector on a pledge to support the nominees of the presidential ticket that won the state’s popular vote,” they wrote.

Baca vs. Colorado Department of State stems from the 2016 election, in which Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton won the statewide vote. However, one member of Colorado’s electoral college, Micheal Baca, tried to cast his vote for Ohio’s then-governor, Republican John Kasich.

Then-Secretary of State Wayne Williams removed and replaced Baca as an elector, per state law that binds electors to the results of the statewide vote. In August, a three-judge panel sided with Baca.

“Unelected and unaccountable presidential electors should not be allowed to decide the presidential election without regard to voters’ choices and state law,” said Secretary of State Jena Griswold on Wednesday. 

A presidential ticket needs 270 electoral votes nationally to win. While the winner typically receives the most popular votes too, the elections of 2000 and 2016 were exceptions.

The General Assembly this year passed the “National Popular Vote Compact,” entering Colorado into a coalition of states representing 196 electoral votes that would agree to bind their electors to the winner of the national popular vote. 

Opponents collected enough signatures to prompt a referendum of the law on next year’s ballot.

South Dakota, one of the signatories to the Nov. 20 amicus curiae brief, has a longstanding tradition of electors casting their votes for the presidential ticket that won the most votes in the state.

However, given “increasing polarization” and rising numbers of faithless electors, “South Dakota must now consider whether to join the ranks of states which bind their electors by law to their party’s nominee,” the brief reads. One faithless elector in the state would affect one-third of the state’s three electoral votes.

The state attorneys general argue that the country’s founders purposefully had no one design for the electoral college, leaving it up to states. Furthermore, states can replace electors who die or move out of state, so it follows that regulating faithless electors falls within their authority.

Whatever the final verdict, the attorneys general asked the Supreme Court to take up the case quickly, given the proximity of the next presidential election and the fact that the August ruling applies only to the states in the 10th Circuit.

“The lower court’s decision may rally more electors to cast faithless ballots in future elections, potentially causing disputed outcomes,” they wrote.

In this Dec. 19, 2016, file photo, Colorado elector Micheal Baca, second from left, talks with legal counsel after he was removed from the panel for voting for a different candidate than the one who won the popular vote, during the Electoral College vote at the Capitol in Denver. Colorado Secretary of State Wayne Williams, front right, looks on. On Tuesday, Aug. 20, 2019, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Williams violated the Constitution when he removed Baca from the panel.
(File photo by Brennan Linsley, Associated Press)
Tags

PREV

PREVIOUS

Former Colorado councilman pleads guilty to felony theft

ASPEN – A former Aspen councilman and ski company executive has pleaded guilty to felony theft between $100,000 and $1 million. Aspen Daily News reported Monday that 52-year-old Derek Johnson entered his plea after authorities say he sold SkiCo skis and snowboards on eBay between June 2013 and January 2019. Prosecutors say Johnson faces up to 12 […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

East Colfax Community Collective calls for greater protections against resident displacement

The East Colfax Community Collective, a newly formed grassroots organization advocating for anti-displacement policies, held a press conference Tuesday ahead of the East Area Plan workshop scheduled this Saturday to voice community concerns and call for more equitable and inclusive engagement with its most vulnerable residents. Collective leaders highlighted challenges facing renters, refugees and the […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests