Colorado Politics

Passion and Pinocchios run high as Colorado leaders react to tax reform

After Republicans in the U.S. Senate passed its version of a tax reform bill early Saturday, passions, rhetoric and threats rippled across the Colorado political landscape this weekend, proving hyperbole is the mother’s milk of politics.

Republicans, predictably, argued that lower taxes, especially on corporations, is the salve the economy needs to help lower and middle-come families, while Democrats see a recipe for utter disaster if the bill makes it to President Trump’s desk to become law.

The Senate bill got no Democratic support, and Republican Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee voted against because the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office estimates the legislation could add $1.47 trillion to federal deficit over a decade.

Republicans argue that economic growth will cover the tab.

Sen. Cory Gardner, a Republican from Yuma, flagged the bill’s benefits for everyday folks. He pointed to the expansion of the child tax credit from $1,000 to $2,000. The bill also preserves the mortgage interest deductions for homeowners.

Gardner said every income bracket would pay less in taxes, while Democrats point at the unequal tilt toward the rich, at the expense of the federal deficit and social programs for the poor.

“Coloradans will keep more of their own money in their own pockets, and the American people will be able to invest their savings the way they want to, not how Washington dictates,” Gardner said in a statement this weekend.

Sure, the Senate bill cuts the corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 20 percent, but high taxes drive jobs and business investment to other countries, Gardner contends.

“We know workers bear much of the burden of the corporate tax rate and lowering the corporate tax rate will lead to bigger paychecks for hard-working Coloradans,” Gardner said.

Slow your roll there, senator. Define “much.” And, economically speaking, bigger paychecks is more hoping than governing.

FactChecker.org noted in September. “Three nonpartisan organizations – the Joint Committee on Taxation, the Congressional Budget Office and Tax Policy Center – all say the majority of the corporate tax burden falls on shareholders, not workers. The Treasury Department, which Mnuchin now heads, reached that same conclusion in 2008 during the George W. Bush administration.”

Gardner also said, “The United States has the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world and in order for our businesses to be competitive, this must change.”

Several fact-checkers say that is true only if it is assumed that all corporations pay the top statutory rate with no deductions or credits.

The reality is different.

The Congressional Budget Office reported in March  that while the U.S. has the top rate allowed by law, 39 percent in federal and localized taxes, in reality the average charged to a corporation is about 29 percent, which puts it third behind Argentina and Indonesia.

Further, after credits and deductions, the average rate corporations pay is 18.6 percent, which is lower than the rates in Argentina, Japan and the United Kingdom, according to the CBO.

ProgressNow Colorado executive director Ian Silverii had a short, threatening statement about the GOP tax plan. The state’s leading liberal organization cited “massive future cuts to vital programs like Social Security and Medicare to give the wealthiest Americans including President Donald Trump a tax cut.”

“Cory Gardner will lose his seat for this,” Silverii predicted.

Democratic Sen. Michael Bennet got on a rhetorical roll about the tax bill on the Senate floor Friday, and his impassioned words also got ahead of his facts.

“Republicans claim this plan pays for itself, just like they claimed when they cut taxes in 2001 and 2003,” he said in a statement Saturday. “It won’t. Instead, this plan borrows over $1 trillion from our kids and grandkids. It is the sons and daughters of Colorado’s teachers, firefighters, and police officers who will have to pay back that bill. And for what? To end poverty in America? No. To invest in infrastructure or health care? No. To strengthen our safety net? No. But to fritter it away on tax cuts for the wealthiest people in America.”

OK, that’s probably solid, or close enough for his opinion. But then Bennet skated out onto the factual thin ice to join Gardner.

On the Senate floor Friday, Bennet called the GOP tax cuts under the second President Bush “supply-side economics, which is exactly the same move that we’re seeing today. (It) resulted in the worst recession since the Great Depression.”

The Washington Post Fact Checker gave Hillary Clinton three Pinocchios when she made the same claim last year.

“It’s difficult to summarize vast economic changes in a single sentence – and economists will forever argue on root causes of the crash. But Clinton’s effort to pin much of the blame on Bush’s tax cuts is rhetorical poppycock,” The Post deemed the tax cut/recession theory.

Adam Fox, director of strategic engagement for the left-leaning Colorado Consumer Health Initiative and the coalition organizer for the Protect Our Care Colorado Coalition, accused Republicans of theft and deceit.

“Senate Republicans successfully deceived their constituents and crammed their horrendous tax heist down the gullet of the average American today,’ he said. “At its core, this bill takes health coverage from working families to give tax cuts to the wealthiest 1 percent and multinational corporations.”

Protect Our Care Colorado is a coalition of 48 organizations.

Colorado state Democratic Party chairwoman Morgan Carroll, a former state senator who lost her race to unseat congressman Mike Coffman last year, proved she had the brinksmanship chops for D.C. politics.

“This bill is a moral abomination and an absolute disaster for anyone who isn’t a millionaire, a billionaire, or a corporation,” Carroll said in a statement.

 

PREV

PREVIOUS

Americans for Prosperity Colorado to try one last time to save voucher program in DougCo

Is there any way to save the Douglas County voucher program from its all-but-certain demise on Monday? Americans for Prosperity Colorado (AFP), which spent “six figures” during the election season trying to persuade voters to support the then-board majority’s reform efforts, announced Friday it would try. David Ray, president of the Douglas County board of […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

Colorado senators working to keep CHIP program in place for needy kids, pregnant women

Keeping the state’s CHIP program – Children’s Health Insurance Plan – in place for kids and pregnant mothers is at the forefront of concerns in Washington and Colorado. Funding is set to cease for the program at the end of January unless Congress acts quickly to reauthorize it. Finance Committee chairman and lead author of […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests